Tempest Book Nears Completion

Posted By on June 28, 2012

Hellen Mirren (Prospera), Felicity Jones (Miranda), and Djimon Hounsou (Caliban) in Julia Taymor's film adaptation of The Tempest

I spent the last ten days at Lynne and Michael Kositsky’s in Ontario while Lynne and I worked through a final proofreading of the Tempest book. There are a still a few loose ends before we deliver the manuscript on July 14 – but the lion’s share of the work is done, much to our relief. Writing the book was by far the most difficult thing I’ve done in my life, with the possible exception of the de Vere Bible dissertation. 

Now that it’s done, we can consider the next question of how influential it will turn out to be. I hope it will make an impact not only within Tempest studies but also the larger questions of authorship which are inextricably embedded in any discussion of when The Tempest was written.  We do not take up any of these other considerations in our book, which we wanted to be focus exclusively on the play, not on who wrote it — but we all know that such larger considerations are the crux of much interest in this play at this point in the development of our knowledge in 2012. Stratfordians are interested in William Strachey — we found something much more interesting in our book.  We will of course rely on readers to help us see how far we may have succeeded in rendering our conclusions persuasive to both a general and a more specialized readership.  Some of the book is highly technical. But I think we have done a reasonably good job of communicating even the technical details in language that is routinely comprehensible. Knock on wood.

But from where I sit, although the book no doubt has flaws, the case it makes for a Tempest not influenced a whit by Strachey and written at least eight years earlier than popularly believed, for original Shrovetide production perhaps in 1599 or 1603, is pretty overwhelming. I find it hard to visualize in my mind’s eye any response except that Shakespearean orthodoxy will be able to look at the book and say, “damn.”

I think this will especially be the case in those parts of the book where for the first time we are allowed to articulate our response to the remarks made by Mr. Tom Reedy in Review of English Studies in 2010,  and those of Professor Alden Vaughan in The Shakespeare Quarterly in 2008.

Both RES and the Shakespeare Quarterly refused us any right of response. I’m told that journals in the sciences which do that are regarded by practitioners as breaking the normative standards of scholarly discourse (which to them by definition almost means that work originally published in a specific journal and subsequently criticized in it has a right of reply).  Apparently things are different in literary studies, where we just do what we want.

Of course, the industrious scrubbers for a world with a very safe Shakespeare who wasn’t very smart and wouldn’t know Shrovetide if it bit him on the ass will think of something more entertaining than “damn” to say. But mostly I think there will be a very loud gnashing of the teeth and a mad rush for the exit sign, behind which are found a crew of elves banging away to nail down the “Jacobean” composition dates of Lear, Pericles, Winter’s Tale, and the other usual suspects.   Yes Virginia, there is a real Shakespeare. We’re just not going to tell you his name.


About the author

Roger Stritmatter is a native liberal humorist who lives in Baltimore, Maryland. Contrary to rumor, he does not live on North Avenue. He does, however, work on North Avenue. A pacifist by inclination, one of his heroes is John Brown. But he thinks that Fredrick Douglass, another of his heroes, made the right decision. Stritmatter's primary areas of interest include the nature of paradigm shifts, the history of ideas, forensic literary studies, MS studies, renaissance literature, and the history of the Shakespearean question, the latter a field in which he has published extensively.


5 Responses to “Tempest Book Nears Completion”

  1. An vast powerful ocean is pushing behind the dam that is going to come apart at the seams, and we look forward to your work helping to break it open. Perhaps it will be that one added force of strength triggering the flood. Wishing you and Lynne the greatest success with it!

  2. A vast powerful ocean is pushing behind the dam that is going to come apart at the seams, and we look forward to your work helping to break it open. Perhaps it will be that one added force of strength triggering the flood. Wishing you and Lynne the greatest success with it!

  3. Lurking Ox says:

    Stratfordians are such funny people. I am on pins and needles to discover the new Stratfordian caboose. Can’t wait for the book!

  4. William Ray says:

    If your book closes the door on the stock authorship denial, “unfortunately ten Shakespearean plays were written after Oxford died”, are the Stratfordian advocates going to be honest-minded enough to drop their ideological doctrine, ‘Up-from-no-evidence-works-for-me’? And is a blackball part of that ideological attempt to stave off honest-mindedness.

    These may be significant problems to deal with in the coming years and to anticipate with some serious thought now.

    with the best wishes,

    William Ray

  5. Roger Stritmatter says:

    Thanks Hank, LO, and William, for the thoughtful kind words. Blackballing has been a significant part of the orthodox strategy for as long as I can remember, and seems likely to continue so for the forseeable future. Take any group of people who have been as wrong as these have for so long about so much and you aren’t going to get polite when the damn bursts. You will get a lot of yowling. On the other hand, a small but significant number are inexorably moving away from the center of the herd and situating themselves as independent thinkers willing to make strategic concessions insofar as they are able. So I think we need to encourage and cultivate that as much as possible. William, how did the showing of *Anonymous* go? Sorry I didn’t get to see you guys on this trip. Signing off from Portland after some real adventures, including landing my first two steelhead ever on the Deschutes last week, not to mention seeing a Mountain Lion up close on the downriver drift. You know you are in the west when that happens. 🙂

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Categories

  • Archives

In "From Crackpot to Mainstream"Keir Cutler, PhD, takes down the recent Shakespeare Beyond Doubt (OUP, 2013)

Criticism of Cutler's "Is Shakespeare Dead?": "A magnificently witty performance!" (Winnipeg Sun). "Highly entertaining and engrossing!" (EYE Weekly). "Is Shakespeare Dead? marshals startling facts into an elegant and often tenacious argument that floats on a current of delicious irony" (Montreal Gazette).